Como o chalá é separado de tumah em um festival? [ie, se a massa se tornou impura, de modo que o chalá retirado dela não é adequado ao consumo por um Cohein, como pode ser separado no festival de Pessach? Não pode ser assado em Pessach, pois não é adequado para consumo. Não pode sobrar para ser queimado à noite, pois pode se tornar chametz. Não é permitido alimentá-lo com cães, pois é proibido destruir alimentos consagrados em um festival.] R. Eliezer diz: Não o chame pelo nome ("chalá") até que esteja assado, [para que cada um ( pão) é adequado para ele, pois de cada pão ele se separa um pouco. E depois de assado, se ele desejar, ele pode separar a chalá completa para todos. Para R. Eliezer sustenta que, se alguém pega (pães) do forno e os coloca em uma cesta, todos combinam para (fins de) chalá.] R. Yehudah diz: Deixe que (a massa separada) seja colocada em água fria (para que não se torne chametz.)] R. Yehoshua disse: Este não é o chametz contra o qual somos exortados em bal yeraeh e bal yimatzeh. [Pois não é dele depois que ele o chama pelo nome, e está escrito (Êxodo 13: 7): "... não vos será visto"—O que é seu, você pode não ver, mas pode ver o dos outros e o dos Exaltados. E este não é seu, nem o do seu vizinho, ainda não tendo chegado às mãos do Cohein. E R. Eliezer sustenta que, se desejar, ele pode pedir (absolvição por sua dedicação), é dedicação em erro, portanto, não dedicação, e, portanto, adequado para ele comer e (considerado) o chametz de um Israelita. E R. Yehoshua sustenta que não dizemos: "Desde que ele deseje, etc." A halachá está de acordo com R. Eliezer.]
Bartenura on Mishnah Pesachim
חלה בטומטה – the starter-dough that became impure and furthermore, Hallah that is appropriate for the Kohen to eat is not taken from it, how then would we separate it (i.e., the Hallah) on the holiday of Passover? WE are not able to bake it on Passover after it is not worthy of being eaten, and to keep it around and then burn it in the evening is impossible, lest it ferment. And to feed it to dogs is impossible for we do not get rid of holy things on Holy Days.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
English Explanation of Mishnah Pesachim
Introduction
This mishnah discusses a halakhic quandary. In order to understand it we need to first mention some background halakhot.
1) When one prepares dough there is a mitzvah to separate some dough. This separated dough is called hallah (Numbers 15:20). If the dough is ritually clean it is given to a Kohen; if it is ritually unclean it cannot be eaten and must be burned.
2) On Pesah all dough needs to be baked immediately lest it become chametz.
3) On festivals one is allowed to cook food, but one is not allowed to cook food which cannot be eaten.
4) One is not allowed to burn sacred things in order to remove them on a festival. This includes challah, which is considered sacred.
The problem then is what to do with baking unclean hallah on one of the festival days of Pesah. If she bakes it then she may be transgressing the laws of the festival which allows one to cook only food which can be eaten. The unclean hallah cannot be eaten so it can’t be baked. She can’t burn it either. If she just leaves it, it will ferment and become chametz.
In our mishnah the rabbis debate what to do with this dough.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
Bartenura on Mishnah Pesachim
רבי אליעזר אומר לא יקרא לה שם חלה עד שתאפה – and still each and every is appropriate [for separating out Hallah] and from each and every one we separate a small amount, and after baking it, if he wanted, he can separate a complete Hallah on the entire thing. For Rabbi Eliezer holds that he who detaches bread from where it sticks to the oven and puts it in a basket, the basket combines [the pieces] for Hallah.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
English Explanation of Mishnah Pesachim
How do they separate hallah on the festival [from dough which is] in [a state of] uncleanness? Rabbi Eliezer says: she should not call it [hallah] until it is baked. Rabbi Eliezer tries to find a means to avoid the problem. Usually, one separates and designates dough as hallah while it is still dough, before it is baked. In this case, to avoid the problem, what the woman baking the dough should do is not designate which piece will be hallah until after it has been baked. In this way, while the loaves are being baked, we could point to each loaf and say, “this one will not be hallah.” After it has already been cooked we need not be concerned about it becoming chametz. In the evening, she may burn the unclean hallah.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
Bartenura on Mishnah Pesachim
לא זהו חמץ שמוזהרים עליו – for it is not his after he has designated it (literally ‘called it by name’) and it is written in Scripture (Exodus 13:7): “no leaven shall be found [in your territory].” Yours you cannot see but you can see that of others and of “On High” (i.e., God). And this is not yours nor of your friends, for yet it has not reached the hand of the Kohen. But Rabbi Eliezer holds that since if he desires, he may bring up a case for decision [from a Sage] that is dedicated [to the Temple] in error and that is not something dedicated and it is appropriate for eating. It is found that it is his and it is the leaven of an Israelite. But Rabbi Yehoshua holds that we don’t say, ‘Since.” But the Halakha is according to Rabbi Eliezer.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
English Explanation of Mishnah Pesachim
Rabbi Judah ben Batera says: she should put [the dough] into cold water. Rabbi Judah ben Batera comes up with a different solution. Separate the hallah when it is still dough, but instead of baking it put it in cold water. The cold water will arrest the fermentation process.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
English Explanation of Mishnah Pesachim
Rabbi Joshua said: this is not the chametz concerning which we are warned with, “It shall not be seen”, and “It shall not be found”. Rather she separates it and leaves it until the evening, and if it ferments it ferments. Rabbi Joshua rejects both of the previous solutions and rather says that she should separate the dough and if it becomes chametz then it becomes chametz. There is no need to be concerned that this is a transgression. The Torah’s prohibitions “It (chametz) shall not be seen” (Exodus 13:7) and “It shall not be found” (Exodus 12:19) do not apply to this chametz because it doesn’t belong to its owners anymore. From the minute she separates it to make it challah it already belongs to the kohen.
