Se uno beve beneficia del suo vicino ed entra per visitarlo, può stare in piedi, ma non sedersi. [La nostra Mishnah parla della proprietà del visitatore che è vietata al malato, in un posto in cui si è pagati per stare con una persona malata, in modo che se si siede con lui e non prende il pagamento abituale, lo beneficia. Ma stare in piedi è solo per un breve periodo e non è consuetudine pagare per questo.] E può guarirlo, la guarigione dell'anima [cioè il suo corpo], ma non la guarigione della proprietà [la guarigione della sua bestia. Perché uno è obbligato a guarire il suo amico se si ammala, vale a dire. (Deuteronomio 22: 2): "E tu glielo restituirai"—per includere il restauro corporeo (cioè la guarigione), e quindi fa una mitzvah. Pertanto, anche se ha rinunciato a trarre beneficio da lui, può guarirlo con le sue mani (cioè direttamente) quando si ammala. Ma se la sua bestia è malata, potrebbe non curarla con le sue mani perché lo avvantaggia così. Tuttavia, potrebbe dirgli: questo farmaco fa bene; questa droga fa male.] E può fare il bagno con lui in una grande vasca, ma non in una piccola. [Perché lo beneficia "sollevando" l'acqua su di lui.] E può dormire con lui in un letto. R. Yehudah dice: In estate, ma non in inverno [perché lo riscalda. L'halachah è conforme a R. Yehudah.] E può sedersi con lui su un letto e può mangiare con lui a un tavolo, ma non dal Tamchui. [Non può mangiare con lui da un piatto, per non lasciarlo mangiare una "buona porzione" di esso, in modo che l'altro, che ha bevuto beneficio da lui, lo mangi; o per non avvicinare un pezzo a lui in modo da mangiarlo, beneficiando così di lui.] Ma può mangiare da un tamchui che ritorna [al proprietario. Reuven può mangiare da un piatto che sa che verrà rispedito a Shimon, che ne ha beneficiato, dopo che è tornato al proprietario. E non ci preoccupiamo che potrebbe lasciare qualcosa nel piatto per Shimon da mangiare, beneficiando così lui.] Potrebbe non mangiare con lui dall'evus (posto) davanti agli operai, [un grande recipiente che riempirebbero di cibo e da cui i lavoratori avrebbero mangiato insieme], e potrebbe non lavorare con lui insieme sul letto di frontiera. Queste sono le parole di R. Meir. [Non può raccogliere con lui nella stessa fila che sta raccogliendo, perché lo aiuta a finire rapidamente il suo lavoro fornendo spazi aperti davanti a lui, beneficiando così di lui. L'halachah non è conforme a R. Meir.] I saggi dicono: Potrebbe lavorare a distanza da lui.
Bartenura on Mishnah Nedarim
עומד אבל לא יושב – our Mishnah deals with when those who visit [the sick] enter who are forbidden [by vow] to the sick. But in a place where they take payment on sitting with the infirm person, for if he sits with him and doesn’t take his customary payment, he causes him benefit. But standing, it is a short time and it is not customary to take payment for this.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
English Explanation of Mishnah Nedarim
Introduction
The mishnah deals with several types of benefit that Shimon must refrain from giving Reuven who has sworn (or been sworn by Shimon) not to receive benefit from him.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
Bartenura on Mishnah Nedarim
רפואת הנפש – the healing of his body.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
English Explanation of Mishnah Nedarim
If one is forbidden to benefit from his neighbor, and he pays him a visit [in sickness] he must stand, but not sit. Shimon may visit Reuven when he is sick, because that is a mitzvah. However, he shouldn’t sit with him for a long time, because that would be causing benefit to Reuven.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
Bartenura on Mishnah Nedarim
רפואת ממונן – the healing of his cattle/beast. For it is obligatory for a person to heal his fellow when he takes ill, as it states (Deuteronomy 22:2): “then you shall give it back to him,” to include he loss of his body, and he is doing a Mitzvah, therefore, even though he made a vow not to allow him to derive any benefit from him, he heals him with his hands when he becomes sick in his body. But if his beast/cattle became ill, he is not able to heal it with his hands because he provides benefit, but says to him: “this drug/medication is fine for it (i.e., the animal), [or] that drug/medication is bad/harmful for it (i.e., the animal).
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
English Explanation of Mishnah Nedarim
He may afford him a cure of life, but not a cure of money. The Talmud explains that Shimon may help cure Reuven for that is a commandment. However, he may not cure Reuven’s animal for that is a monetary benefit.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
Bartenura on Mishnah Nedarim
אבל לא בקטנה – because he provides benefit t him when he raises the water over him.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
English Explanation of Mishnah Nedarim
He may bathe together with him in a large bath, but not in a small one. If Shimon gets into a small bath with Reuven, he will raise the level of the bath water, and thereby benefit Reuven. Therefore he may not do so. However, he may get into a large bath with him where the water level will barely be raised.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
Bartenura on Mishnah Nedarim
אבל לא בימות הגשמים – because he warms it (i.e., through his body) And the Halakha is according to Rabbi Yehuda.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
English Explanation of Mishnah Nedarim
He may sleep in a bed with him. Rabbi Judah said: in summer, but not in winter, because he thereby benefits him. He may [nevertheless] recline with him on a couch. He may sleep in bed with him, even though he warms up the bed. Rabbi Judah restricts this to the summer months, when it is warm anyway. However, even Rabbi Judah agrees that he may recline with him on the same couch, and we are not concerned lest he fall asleep.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
Bartenura on Mishnah Nedarim
אבל לא מן המחוי – he doesn’t eat with him in one utensil, lest he leave over from eating a nice portion that is within in order that this one who took a vow against deriving benefit from him will eat, or lest a piece that he eat draws close in front of him and it is found that he benefitting him.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
English Explanation of Mishnah Nedarim
[He may] eat at the same table with him but not out of the same bowl; but he may eat with him out of a bowl which returns. He may not eat with him out of the food trough put before laborers. Reuven may eat at the same table as Shimon, and we are not concerned lest Reuven eats from Shimon’s plate and thereby derives benefit. However, they may not eat out of the same communal bowl, lest Shimon intentionally leave the best part of the food for Reuven, and thereby cause him benefit. If the communal bowl was a “returning bowl” meaning one that was full of food, such that each person eating could eat his fill and still have leftovers, then they may share. In such a case, there is no concern that Shimon will leave food for Reuven because there is enough for everyone. They may not eat out of the same bowl put before laborers, because laborers are always hungry and there are never leftovers. Therefore, Shimon might eat less so that Reuven could eat more.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
Bartenura on Mishnah Nedarim
אבל אוכל הוא מן התמחוי החוזר – the owner of the house. Reuven eats in a bowl that he knows that when he will return it to the owner of the house, the house owner will go back and send it to Shimon who is under a vow against benefit from him, and we don’t suspect lest he (i.e., the owner of the house) in order that Shimon will eat from it and it is found that he is benefitting him.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
English Explanation of Mishnah Nedarim
He may not work with him on the same furrow, the words of Rabbi Meir. But the Sages say: he may work at a distance from him. According to Rabbi Meir they may not work plowing the same furrow, since if Shimon works harder he will benefit Reuven by allowing him to work less. The Sages allow them to work in the same furrow, as long as they keep their distance.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
Bartenura on Mishnah Nedarim
האבוס שלפני הפועלים – a large utensil that we fill it and all of the workers will eat from it together.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
Bartenura on Mishnah Nedarim
לא יקצור עמו באומן – he should not trim with in in the same row that he trims. For this causes him that he will hurry to do his work that when he finds the place free, and it is found tha the benefits him. But the Halakha is not according to Rabbi Meir.
