Se uno proibisce a sua moglie di voto di convivenza [come quando dice: "Lascia che il godimento della tua convivenza sia proibito a me" (Ma se dice: "Il godimento della mia convivenza è proibito a te", non è vietata, poiché le è obbligato, essendo scritto (Esodo 21:10): "... e il suo tempo (coniugale) non dovrà trattenere")] —Beth Shammai dice: due settimane. [Se ha giurato così, deve aspettare due settimane (prima di riprendere le relazioni); poiché così troviamo con una donna che ha dato alla luce una femmina, che è impura per due settimane.] Beth Hillel dice: Una settimana. [Per questo troviamo, rispetto a una niddah, che è impura per sette giorni; e deriviamo ciò che è comune (un uomo che si arrabbia con sua moglie e le proibisce per voto) da ciò che è comune (niddah, che è un evento comune)—al contrario del parto, che non è così comune. E Beth Shammai sostiene che deriviamo qualcosa che egli provoca (il voto dell'uomo, che la fa desistere), da qualcosa che egli provoca (il parto, che lo attraversa)—al contrario di niddah, che viene da se stesso. Se (le proibisce) più di una settimana secondo Beth Hillel, o più di due settimane secondo Beth Shammai, deve mandarla via e darle la sua kethubah—anche se era un cammelliere, il cui tempo coniugale è una volta ogni trenta giorni, o un marinaio, il cui tempo coniugale è una volta ogni sei mesi.] Gli studiosi della Torah possono partire per lo studio della Torah senza (le loro mogli) il permesso per trenta giorni. [Questa Mishnah è conforme a R. Eliezer. I rabbini differiscono da lui, dicendo che potrebbe farlo per due o tre anni. L'halachah è conforme ai saggi.] I lavoratori possono farlo per una settimana. Il tempo coniugale menzionato nella Torah: tayalin [che non ha né lavoro né affari], ogni giorno; lavoratori, due volte a settimana; autisti di asino [che portano fasci di cammelli da lontano], una volta ogni trenta giorni; marinai [che salparono sul Mediterraneo], una volta ogni sei mesi. Queste sono le parole di R. Eliezer. [E se all'inizio uno era un commerciante il cui tempo coniugale è frequente e desiderava passare a un'occupazione il cui tempo coniugale è poco frequente, sua moglie può impedirlo— tranne se desiderava studiare la Torah, la moglie non era in grado di impedire a suo marito, che era un tayal o un lavoratore di diventare uno studioso della Torah.]
Bartenura on Mishnah Ketubot
המדיר את אשתו מתשמיש המטה – aa for example, that he said: the benefit of your sexual intercourse will be forbidden upon me, but the benefit of my sexual intercourse will be forbidden to you; he is not forbidden for he is subjugated to her, as it is written (Exodus 21:10): “he must not withhold her conjugal rights.”
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
English Explanation of Mishnah Ketubot
Introduction
This mishnah teaches that a husband has an obligation to have sexual relations with his wife. How frequently he is obligated depends on his job.
The idea that a husband has an obligation to periodically have relations with his wife is derived from Exodus 21:10 which states that if a man takes a second wife he cannot diminish from her three things: food, clothing or conjugal rights. With regard to our issue, if a man has two or more wives he must provide each one with their conjugal rights. You can imagine that this might have been one deterrent to the practice of polygyny (the proper term for the practice of men marrying more than one woman).
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
Bartenura on Mishnah Ketubot
ב"ש אומרים שתי שבתות – if he took a vow for two weeks, she should wait, for such as we found with a woman who gives birth to a female who is ritually impure for two weeks.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
English Explanation of Mishnah Ketubot
A man forbade himself by vow from having intercourse with his wife: Beth Shammai says: two weeks; Beth Hillel says: one week. A man cannot make a vow to forbid upon his wife anything which he is mandated to give her by law. The man in this mishnah, perhaps in a fit of anger, forbade his wife from have sexual relations with him. This is not permitted and if he does not have his vow annulled (a process we will discuss in tractate Nedarim), he must divorce her and pay her the ketubah. However, he is not obligated to divorce her that very day; rather he is given a period to cool off and hopefully have his vow annulled. According to Beth Shammai he is given two weeks and according to Beth Hillel he is given only one week. After that length of time, he must divorce her and pay her the ketubah.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
Bartenura on Mishnah Ketubot
וב"ה אומרים שבת אחת – for such we have found with a menstruant woman who is ritually impure for seven [days] and we learn something that is frequent. The anger [that a person expresses] over his wife and takes a vow concerning her is something that is frequent, [which we learn] from the menstruant woman something that is frequent, to exclude giving birth which is not all that frequent. But the School of Shammai holds that we learn something that he caused to her. The vow of a man which he causes her to wait/delay from giving birth, which is upon his hand comes upon her, to exclude the menstruant woman that of its own comes to her. And more than one week according to the School of Hillel and two weeks according to the School of Shammai, he should divorce [her] and give [her] the Ketubah settlement, and even if he was a camel driver whose period is thirty days or a sailor whose period is sixth months.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
English Explanation of Mishnah Ketubot
Students may go away to study Torah, without the permission [of their wives for a period of] thirty days; workers for one week. Since a husband must have relations with his wife, he cannot be away from her for a long period of time. According to this section, a Torah scholar cannot leave his wife without her permission for longer than thirty days. A worker can be out of town for only one week. If either wish to remain away from their wives for a longer period of time, they must receive permission.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
Bartenura on Mishnah Ketubot
התלמידים וכו' שלשים יום – and our Mishnah is according to Rabbi Eliezer and the Rabbis dispute it and state even two or three years, and the Halakha is according to the Sages.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
English Explanation of Mishnah Ketubot
The times for conjugal duty prescribed in the torah are: For independent men, every day; For workers, twice a week; For donkey-drivers, once a week; For camel-drivers, once in thirty days; For sailors, once in six months. These are the words of Rabbi Eliezer. This section delineates how often in general a husband must be available to have relations with his wife. The frequency depends on his occupation. An independent man, meaning one who doesn’t work, must have relations with his wife every day. Note that this does not mean that he actually has to do so, but rather that if she so desires, he is obligated. He cannot claim that he is too busy to have sex with her. Workers must be available twice a week. The Talmud explains that this refers to workers who work in the city; those who work outside the city are obligated only once a week, as we learned in the previous clause. Donkey-drivers, who travel short distances must be available once a week. Camel-drivers who travel longer distances must be available once a month and finally, sailors who travel for long periods of time, need to return home once every six months. This all refers to situations where the wife has not given her husband permission. If she has given him permission, he may stay away longer. She might give him permission if, for instance, for the sake of supporting the family, the husband had to be away for a long period of time. However, it is her right to demand that he find work closer to home.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
Bartenura on Mishnah Ketubot
הטיילים – who have no work nor business.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
Bartenura on Mishnah Ketubot
החמרים – who go out to the villages to bring grain.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
Bartenura on Mishnah Ketubot
הגמלים – who bring packages on the camels from a place far away.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
Bartenura on Mishnah Ketubot
הספנים – who go on a voyage to the Great Sea (Mediterranean). He who his beginning was the master of a craft whose period [permitted before he must have sexual relations with his wife] is close and he requested to become the master of a craft whose period is further off, his wife waits for him, except for that of the study of Torah where the woman is unable to wait for her husband who was at leisure ora worker who does not become a Sage.
