Comentário sobre Baba Batra 9:2
הִנִּיחַ בָּנִים וּבָנוֹת וְטֻמְטוּם, בִּזְמַן שֶׁהַנְּכָסִים מְרֻבִּים, הַזְּכָרִים דּוֹחִין אוֹתוֹ אֵצֶל נְקֵבוֹת. נְכָסִים מֻעָטִין, הַנְּקֵבוֹת דּוֹחוֹת אוֹתוֹ אֵצֶל זְכָרִים. הָאוֹמֵר אִם תֵּלֵד אִשְׁתִּי זָכָר יִטֹּל מָנֶה, יָלְדָה זָכָר, נוֹטֵל מָנֶה. נְקֵבָה מָאתַיִם, יָלְדָה נְקֵבָה, נוֹטֶלֶת מָאתָיִם. אִם זָכָר מָנֶה אִם נְקֵבָה מָאתַיִם, וְיָלְדָה זָכָר וּנְקֵבָה, זָכָר נוֹטֵל מָנֶה וְהַנְּקֵבָה נוֹטֶלֶת מָאתָיִם. יָלְדָה טֻמְטוּם, אֵינוֹ נוֹטֵל. אִם אָמַר כָּל מַה שֶּׁתֵּלֵד אִשְׁתִּי יִטֹּל, הֲרֵי זֶה יִטֹּל. וְאִם אֵין שָׁם יוֹרֵשׁ אֶלָּא הוּא, יוֹרֵשׁ אֶת הַכֹּל:
Se alguém deixa filhos e filhas e um tumulo [aquele cujo sexo, masculino ou feminino, está em dúvida], os homens "o empurram" para as mulheres, [dizendo-lhe: "Prove que você é homem e compartilhe" ( conosco na herança)]. Onde há pouca propriedade, as fêmeas "o empurram" para os machos, [dizendo-lhe: "Prove que você é uma mulher e seja alimentada conosco."] Se alguém disser: "Se minha esposa tiver um macho, deixe ele recebe cem ", se ela deu à luz um homem, ele recebe cem. [E, embora decretemos que "se alguém dá um feto, ele não adquire", aqui estamos falando de um presente no leito de morte para o filho, um homem sendo (mais) disposto favoravelmente em relação ao filho (do que a outros)]. (Se alguém disser: "Se minha esposa tiver uma mulher, deixe-a) duzentos", se ela tiver uma mulher, ela receberá duzentos. (Se ela dissesse :) "Se um homem, cem; se uma mulher duzentos ", se ela deu à luz um homem e uma mulher [gêmeos], o homem recebe cem e a mulher, duzentos. Se ela deu à luz um tumtum, não recebe nada. [Esta Mishnah é rejeitada, e a halachah é que um tumtum recebe o mínimo (quantidade) dos dois.] Se ele dissesse: "O que quer que minha esposa suporte, deixe-o ..." (e acaba sendo um tumtum), ele obtém. E se não houver outro herdeiro, ele herda tudo. [Poderíamos pensar que um tumulo é um tipo distinto de ser e que não é adequado para herdar; portanto, somos avisados de outra forma.]
Bartenura on Mishnah Bava Batra
English Explanation of Mishnah Bava Batra
If a man said, “If my wife shall bear a male he shall be given 100 zuz”, and she had a male, he receives 100 zuz. [If he said, “If my wife shall bear a] female she shall be given 200 zuz”, and she had a female, she receives 200 zuz. [If he said, “If may wife shall bear a] male he shall be given 100 zuz and if a female 200 zuz” and she had a male and a female, the male receives 100 zuz and the female 200 zuz. If she had one of doubtful gender, he does not take. But if he said, “Whatsoever my wife shall bear shall be given [such an amount], he receives.
If he [the one of doubtful gender] was the only heir, he inherits everything.
Mishnah two deals with the division of the inheritance when one of the children is not discernibly male or female and other laws concerning such a child.
This mishnah discusses the rights of a “tumtum” which is the Hebrew term for a child who does not have sexual signs of being a male or female. If there is a large inheritance, and therefore the sons will take their part, the sons can tell the “tumtum” that he is not a son and therefore he can only receive maintenance with the other daughters. If, however, there is small estate, and it is not sufficient to support all of the children, the daughters can tell him that he must go begging with the other sons. These two laws are based on the principle, common to many Rabbinic laws, that the burden of proof is on the plaintiff. In order for the “tumtum” to take part of the inheritance he must prove that he is male, which he cannot. In order for him to receive maintenance when the estate is small, he must prove that he is female, which he cannot.
Section two deals with a father who makes a promise to give his child a present when the child is born and bases the size of the present on the gender of the child. Sections 2, 2a and 2b are straightforward and need no explanation. According to section 2c if, in any of the aforementioned cases, the woman were to bear a “tumtum” the child would not be able to claim the present. Since the present was based on the child’s gender and the child cannot prove a gender, the child cannot make a claim on the gift.
If, however, the father had said that he wished to give a gift to anything that the wife had, then he has not based the gift on the child’s gender. In such a case even a tumtum would receive the gift. Finally the mishnah states that if the “tumtum” were the only inheritor, s/he would inherit.